David Archuleta picked "With You" by Chris Brown on the second round (contestants choice) of American Idol Top 3 performance night.

Randy Jackson said “I am not sure thats the right song. I couldn’t believe it.” Paula Abdul said “Perfect. I think you should be singing songs like this. Great job.” Simon Cowell said “I applaud you however it was like a chihuahua trying to be a tiger. It was a bit awkward.”

CD’s take: The audience loved it! It has the potential to top the iTunes chart.

(Click HERE to watch the video )

Here are the links to David Archuleta’s other performances:

:: And So It Goes – Billy Joel cover

:: Longer – Dan Fogelberg cover