Heejun Han sang ‘Right Here Waiting’ on the American Idol 11 Top 12 show.

Here’s what the judges thought about Heejun Han’s performance:

Randy Jackson: “I didn’t enjoy this at all. It was pitchy all over the place. Also it felt like you were out of breathe the whole time. It was the wrong song, wrong time.”

Steven Tyler: “You stepped so far out of your circle to do this but I love you voice anyways.”

Jennifer Lopez: “I could tell you were struggling with it but towards the end I really loved it.”

Watch the video here: